Interpreting Persephone's Myth
The myth of Persephone is one of the oldest of all Greek myths.
Her story is a personification of some of the most universal
concepts about life and death. In her youth, Persephone represents
the powerful bond between a mother and a daughter and the often
difficult transition from maidenhood to marriage. As the Goddess
of Springtime and Rebirth, she is eternally connected to the
cycles of the earth, which lies barren in her absence and bloom
again each spring with her return. And her initiatory experience
in the realm of the dead is such a powerful experience that it
changes her life forever. It is after this transformation that
we remember her most for her role as the Greek Goddess of the
Underworld.
As the Queen of the Underworld, Persephone is often portrayed
as a force to be feared. In Homer's Iliad (written c.
750-725 BCE) she is described as "grim Persephone" in
direct contrast to her husband Hades, the "mighty Zeus of
the Underworld." In the Odyssey (written c. 743-713
BCE), she has become "dread Persephone" or the "awesome
one," whom mortal men mistrust. We see this when Odysseus
pays a visit to the House of Death. He worries that the vision
of his dead mother, which slips through his fingers and "dissolves
like a dream," is just "some wraith that great Persephone
sends my way to make me ache with sorrow all the more?" (11.244-45).
But his noble mother answers: "This is no deception sent
by Queen Persephone, this is just the way of mortals when we
die" (11.248-249). Yet, when the dead surround him at the
end of his visit, he still flees in fear that "Queen Persephone
might send up from Death some monstrous head, some Gorgon's staring
face!" (11.725-29). The Goddess receives similar treatment
in Hesiod's (c. 700 BCE) Theogony where she is described
as "awful Persephone," who is always at the side of "strong
Hades." Neither of these classic works mentions anything
about the life she led before becoming the Queen of the Dead
or the radiant beauty that attracts Hades enough to want her
for his bride.
There are other stories that view Persephone in a more flattering
light. The most famous of these is the Homeric Hymn to Demeter, which
was written by an unknown author sometime between 650-550 BCE.
The hymn describes Persephone in such complimentary terms as
radiant, noble, and thoughtful. The Greek lyric poet Bacchylides
(c. 520-450 BCE) who, like the hymn, refers to the Goddess as "slender-ankled" (Odes poem
5, line 55), echoes these same sentiments. The tragic playwright
Euripedes (c. 480-406) also sees her in her full glory as "Persephone,
fair young goddess of the netherworld" ("Orestes" line
960). In addition, he brings up the duality of her nature and
her relationship with her mother when he refers to her as "the
goddess of twofold name, Persephone and the kindly goddess Demeter
[ü]" ("Phoenissae" line 680).
Duality is a driving force in many renditions of Persephone's
story. In her younger years she is often called Kore, the grain
or corn maiden, yet once she has made the terrifying transition
into womanhood she is mostly referred to as Persephone. She also
plays a role as the winter Goddess of the Underworld, who cyclically
changes into the springtime Goddess of Rebirth, which are two
very different personifications of the same deity. Günther Zuntz
explains that "no farmer prayed for corn to Persephone;3
no mourner thought of the dead as being with Kore4" (77).
Her duality is also seen as she plays a continuous role as the
feminine counterpart to either her husband, Hades, or her mother,
Demeter. Kerényi sees this double role in even more black
and white terms when he says that: "One of her forms (daughter
with mother) appears as life; the other (young girl with husband)
as death" (107). The ability to integrate all these aspects
of her dualistic life as wife and daughter, innocence and wisdom,
death and rebirth are what makes Persephone such a powerful goddess.
Other interpretations of her story focus on Persephone as one
aspect of the Triple-goddess, a powerful feminine archetype where
maiden, mother and crone are seen as one. While the three
parts of this trinity are sometimes seen as Demeter, Kore and
Persephone, many modern authors focus on Demeter and Persephone's
relationship with the moon-goddess, Hecate. In the Hymn to
Demeter, Hecate is the only one, besides the sun-god, Helios,
to hear Persephone's cries during her abduction. When Persephone
returns from the Underworld, Hecate vows to serve her as her "chief
attendant." Some scholars, such as Patricia Monaghan, even
go so far as to explain that: "The Greek world was divided
into three parts, in honor of the Threefold goddess," with
Hecate wandering the sky, Demeter ruling the surface of the earth,
and Persephone ruling the world of the afterlife (252).
While there may be some ancient clues to indicate that Persephone
could have ventured down to Hades on her own, most versions portray
the "abduction of Persephone" as a central part of
her story. The earliest known artistic representation of her
tale can be found on "a painted wine cup from Phaistos dating
from the middle Minoan period (just before 2000 BCE)" that "shows
two companions crying out while Kore disappears into the earth's
chasm beside the 'flower of deception'" (Lincoln 169).
The flower that lures Persephone to her fate is the narcissus.
According to Robert Graves, Persephone's narcissus, "also
called leirion was the three-petalled blue fleur-de-lys
or iris," which flowers in the fall at the time of her abduction
and is sacred to the Triple-goddess (85.1). Yet most versions
of the story, including the Hymn to Demeter, say that
Persephone was wandering through an entire meadow of beautiful
flowers including roses, crocuses, violets, irises and hyacinths,
when the most lovely of them all caught her eye. It was the sweet-smelling
narcissus with one hundred blooms, "a flower wondrous and
bright, awesome to see, for the immortals above and for mortals
below" (lines 10-11). Enchanted by the beauty of the flower,
Persephone is caught off guard when Hades suddenly emerges from
the earth. As he whisks her away in his "golden four-horsed
chariot," there is no doubt that anyone would cry out from
such a startling event (March 312). Maybe it was the only way
he knew to woo such a beautiful young goddess who had no reason
to travel to his Underworld domain.
There is also conflicting evidence as to who was actually there
to witness Persephone's abduction. Helios and Hecate were the
only names mentioned in the Homeric Hymn to Demeter, but
other versions say a water-nymph named Cyane was there and tried
to stop the proceedings. Yet one thing is certain, once Persephone
is determined to be missing, Demeter is driven to despair.
During Persephone's absence, Demeter looses all interest in
her duties as the Goddess of Agriculture. Some stories say she
roamed the earth in search of her daughter for nine days, and
others mention a nine month hiatus. In the Hymn to Demeter,
it isn't until after she has traveled to Eleusis that Persephone's
mother is finally overcome with such rage and depression that: "For
mortals she ordained a terrible and brutal year on the deeply
fertile earth. The ground released no seed, for bright-crowned
Demeter kept it buried" (lines 305-307). In any case, the
barren landscape is what sets the stage for Persephone to return
again each spring as the Goddess of Rebirth.
Persephone's reunion with her mother is bittersweet. She has
consumed the fruit of the dead, either on her own accord or as
a trick of Hades. In any case, she has been transformed and will
be forced to stay at least part of each year in his domain. Most
stories say she stays there for three months every winter, at
which time Demeter mourns and lets the earth go bare. Other stories
tell of a six month absence in the Underworld. Either way, life
for the young goddess will never be the same. Persephone is now
a wife and Queen, who has been initiated into the mysteries of
the Underworld.
Bruce Lincoln believes that "at some point in prehistory,
probably prior to the arrival of the Indo-Europeans in Greek
regions (ca. 1800 B.C.?), a ritual resembling that described
in the myth was actually performed for some or all women in these
regions upon their arriving at puberty" (167). As the Greek
population grew and moved towards the cities, there was a decline
in initiatory rites of passage into adulthood. The ancient puberty
initiations were modified to become elite Mystery initiations,
which with the rise of democratic ideals eventually became accessible
to the entire population, except barbarians and murderers.
The Eleusinian Mysteries, which focus on the tale of Demeter
and Persephone, were the best known of all ancient Greek initiatory
rites. For centuries they have been studied in the hopes of gaining
insight into their immortal lessons. Contemporary psychologist
James Hillman believes that: "Aspects of the psychological
mystery of Eleusis still take place in the soul today. The Persephone
experience occurs to us each in sudden depressions, when we feel
ourselves caught in hatefulness, cold, numbed, and drawn downward
out of life by a force we cannot see, against which we would
flee" (49). While a strict code of secrecy has revealed
very little information about the actual experience, there are
many records of the transformative power of the initiation. "Reliable
ancient testimony tells that the Mysteries guaranteed a better
life and a different and probably better fate after death" (Foley
70). The words of the Greek lyric poet Pindar (c. 518-438) "tells
us that 'blessed is he who has seen this and thus goes beneath
the earth; he knows the end of life, he knows the beginning given
by Zeus'" (Foley 70).
Another great mystery surrounding the story of Persephone is
whether she was just swept away by Hades or actually raped. A
clue to solving this discrepancy may be found by examining the
transition that occurs in her story as it is translated from
Greek to Latin. There is no mention of rape in any of the early
Greek texts, but we start to see its introduction with the coming
of the Romans near the turn of the century. According to the
research of Bruce Lincoln, all Greek sources describing Hades'
action use the verb harpazein, meaning "to seize,
snatch, carry off," which connotes thievery and violence,
but does not imply rape. In later Latin translations of the texts
the word raptu is used instead, which does imply "abduction,
seizure, rape" (Lincoln 168). The Greek travel-writer Pausanius
from the second century CE mentions the rape of Persephone numerous
times in his ten book series, the Description of Greece.
The concept of Persephone's rape is also covered extensively
in the footnotes of the Library (Bibliotheca), which was
written in the 1st or 2nd century CE, yet attributed to the earlier
Greek scholar Appolodorus (c. 180-120 BCE). The Library also
contains a second version of Persephone's story that suggests
she may have never been abducted in the first place, but was
instead born in Hades to her prolific father Zeus and the Underworld
goddess Styx (bk.1, ch. 3, sect. 1).
During this same period, we see many indications of the demise
of this proud and powerful Greek goddess. According to Appolodorus' Library,
Persephone does not even live in Hades, but in Tartarus. To the
Greeks, this is "a dark and horrible region far below the
earth" (March 367). She no longer dwells in the home of
the ancestors and mighty warriors from the past, but in the gloomiest
part of Hades, where evildoers are condemned to stay forever.
The stories of Appolodorus also portray Persephone as less than
proud in her actions. It is the first time we hear of Persephone's
squabbles with Aphrodite. Their friendship is torn apart over
a beautiful baby named Adonis. Aphrodite is so enchanted with
the child that she steals him for herself and hides him in a
chest that she leaves in Persephone's care. Curious, Persephone
peeks into the box and decides to claim the child for own. The
conflict then goes before Zeus, who decides that Adonis should
spend part of the year with each goddess. Most versions of the
tale say the time is equally split between the two, yet other
portrayals say he spends a third of the year with each goddess
and a third of the year on his own to recover from them both.
I think the time has come for Persephone to regain her dignity
as the great Goddess of the Underworld. Other scholars are also
working to restore the original stories of the lost and ancient
goddesses. Help may even be on the way from another synchronistic
source. Archeologists and other researchers are continuously
digging up new information from the past. An example of this
is the return of the Hymn to Demeter, which was lost for
hundreds of years until it turned up again in a stable in Moscow
in 1777. Other findings may one day help the credibility of the
stories that portray Persephone in all her feminine glory.
One of these ancient stories was able to open my own eyes to
the positive power of Persephone. The tale was put together by
Charlene Spretnak while she was researching the Pre-Hellenic
goddess myths. The story is unique because there is no mention
of the Goddess' abduction into the Underworld, but what really
caught my attention was the idea of Persephone as a psychopomp.
While Greek philosophers such as Sophocles and Plato have acknowledged
Persephone as a "welcomer of the dead," most myths
do not tell this aspect in her story. In Spretnak's version of
the myth, Persephone explains to her mother that there are spirits
who "drift about restlessly" and "hover around
their earthly homes" because they do not understand their
state. She then volunteers to go down to the Underworld and initiate
them into their new life. While at first resisting Persephone's
desire, Demeter comes to understand her motives and leads her
to "a long, deep chasm and produces a torch for Her to carry." When
Persephone finally arrives in the Underworld, she stands on a
rock, with her torch, a vase of her mother's grain, and a large
bowl of "pomegranate seeds, the food of the dead." As
her aura increases in "brightness and warmth," she
introduces herself as Queen of the Dead, and explains to the
spirits that they have left their earthly bodies. She then beckons "those
nearest to step up onto the rock and enter Her aura," where
she embraces them, looks into their eyes, feeds them pomegranate
seeds, and offers them a blessing for renewed "tranquility
and wisdom" (111-116).
Persephone, the ancient Goddess of the Afterlife, still has
much to teach us all today. If we listen carefully to her story,
we may even be able to regain some of the ancient knowledge that
was lost with the last Eleusinian initiate. Persephone still
possesses the power to help us discover the wisdom within that
was able to convince many Greeks that "death is not an evil
but something good" (Foley 71).
Works Cited
Ann, Martha and Dorothy Myers Imel. Goddesses
in World Mythology: A Biographical Dictionary. New York:
Oxford UP, 1993.
Apollodorus. The Library. Trans. Sir
James George Frazer, 2 vol. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP. 1921. The Perseus Project.
Jun. 2000. http://www.perseus.tufts.edu.
Bacchylides. Odes. Ed. Diane Svarlien 1991. Based on
trans. from Maehler's Die Lieder des Bakchylides. (Leiden
1982) and R. C. Jebb's The Poems and Fragments. (Cambridge
1905). The Perseus Project. Jun. 2000. http://www.perseus.tufts.edu.
Euripides. The Complete Greek Drama. Ed. Whitney J. Oates
and Eugene O'Neill, Jr. 2 vol. Trans. E. P. Coleridge. New York.
Random House. 1938. The Perseus Project. Jun. 2000. http://www.perseus.tufts.edu.
Foley, Helene P. Ed. The Homeric Hymn to Demeter: Translation,
Commentary, and Interpretive Essays. Princeton: Princeton
UP, 1994.
Gantz, Timothy. Early Greek Myth: A Guide
to Literary and Artistic Sources. Vol 1. Baltimore:
Johns Hopkins UP, 1993. Click here for Vol 2.
Graves, Robert. The Greek Myths. 2 vols. London:
Penguin, 1960.
Hesiod. "Theogony." The Homeric Hymns and Homerica.
Trans. Hugh G. Evelyn-White. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 1914. The
Perseus Project. Jun. 2000. http://www.perseus.tufts.edu.
Hillman, James. The Dream of the Underworld. New York:
Harper, 1979.
Homer. The Iliad. Trans. Robert Fagles. New York:
Viking, 1990.
Homer. The Odyssey. Trans. Robert Fagles. New
York: Viking, 1996.
Kerényi, C. "Kore." Essays
on the Science of Mythology: The Myth of the Divine Child and
the Mysteries of Eleusis. By
C.G. Jung and C. Kerényi Trans. R.F.C. Hull. Bollingen
Ser. XXII. Princeton: Princeton UP, 1969. 101-155.
Lincoln, Bruce. "The Rape of Persephone." The
Long Journey Home: Re-visioning the Myth of Demeter and Persephone
for Our Time. Ed. Christine Downing. Boston: Shambhala,
1994. 166-172.
March, Jenny. Cassell Dictionary of Classical Mythology. London:
Cassell, 1998.
Monaghan, Patricia. The New Book of
Goddesses & Heroines. St.
Paul, MN: Llewellyn, 1998.
Spretnak, Charlene. Lost Goddesses of Early Greece: A Collection
of Pre-Hellenic Myths. Boston: Beacon, 1978.
Zuntz, Günther. Persephone: Three Essays
on Religion and Thought in Magna Graecia. London: Oxford
UP, 1971.
|