| |
Throughout his career, Carl Gustav Jung was driven
by a deep desire to understand the relationship between the conscious
mind
and the vast realms of the unconscious. His numerous investigations
and personal experiences helped him form the theories behind
what he came to call the "individuation process." The
goal of this process is the powerful sense of wholeness and autonomy
that comes when an individual experiences the integration between
the conscious and unconscious aspects of their psyche. It has
been my own observation that Jung's individuation process shares
many similarities with what I have experienced in my own life
as the artistic process.
As an artist, I continuously experience the ups and downs, dry
spells and flow of ideas, depression and elation that comes along
with my attempt to remain in contact with the unconscious aspects
of my psyche. My constant search for fresh ideas has led to numerous
personal experiences that have convinced me of the vast creative
resources of collective unconscious. Yet, the knowledge of its
existence is not enough, one must seek out methods of communication
and ways to integrate the information once it is discovered.
Jung was a pioneer in this area and there is much that can be
learned from his theories, as both an artist and an individual.
Before attending Pacifica Graduate Institute, I knew
relatively little about Carl Jung. I had a very rudimentary understanding
of psychology,
and
I had never even heard of "depth psychology." Yet,
I knew it was an important aspect of the Mythological Studies
Program, where I was applying. I also realized that I should
do a bit of research
before my first interview. My first introduction to Jung and
his theories came in the form of a cartooned book called Jung
for Beginners. While it did give a brief overview of his
life and work, I remember it most for its portrayal of Jung as
a somewhat crazy genius that was on a spiritual quest to understand
his relationship with his father, the church, and the great unknown
realms of our psyches. The book also made a special point of
discussing Jung's intimate and supposedly sexual relationship
with Freud and his questionable relationship with the Nazi party.
After this rather crass introduction, further readings helped
me understand the great importance of his many contributions
to the field of psychology and our world, particularly those
theories that together are called the individuation process.
Jung describes individuation as "the process by
which a person becomes a psychological 'in-dividual,' that is,
a separate indivisible unity or 'whole'" (212). This idea
captured Jung's interest from the very beginning of his career,
and became the foundation for many of his theories. Jung saw
the individuation process, as "a natural process immanent
in every living organism" (Jacobi 15). It is a process that
can take place unconsciously, or in a variety of natural ways
such as when the "personal experience of the collective
unconscious is opened by dreams and, less commonly, by visions,
hallucinations, synchronistic phenomena, etc." (Jaffé 76).
There is still another way to approach the individuation process,
which is through the "artificial" means of analysis
where a deliberate attempt is made to open a dialog between the
conscious mind and the collective unconscious. For Jung, this
was the ideal method of individuation.
While many praise Jung and his theory of the individuation,
they are not without their critics. Some complain that his theories
are too limited, because they focus mostly on the issues that
occur only in the second half of life; after a person has moved
on from their parents and have set themselves up in their community
with a vocation and family. Another thing to keep in mind in
today's ever-merging cultural environment is that Jung's background
and experience produced ideas that are based on a very Eurocentric
point of view. In fact, Jung was "against Europeans' practicing
yoga or indulging in other 'mysteries' designed for totally alien
psychic structures." He believed "they do not correspond
to the Europeans' state of consciousness and consequently lead
him not to individuation but only into error" (Jacobi 18).
While these concerns and biases are indeed valid, Jung can still
be praised for his faithful attempt to provide a road map of
the path to wholeness and happiness.
Unfortunately, the journey on the road to individuation is often
begun with an unpleasant confrontation with our own shadow.
As the transition is made from the first half of life into the
second, may people encounter obstacles as the neglected aspects
of our psyche attempt to be heard. According to Jacobi: "During
the first half of life there is also formed, as a result of the
necessarily one-sided development of the consciousness, the shadow,
which is the sum qualities conforming to our sex that were neglected
or rejected while the ego was being built up" (38). Jung
adds that: "To become conscious of it involves recognizing
the dark aspects of the personality as present and real. This
act is the essential condition for any kind of self-knowledge,
and it therefore, as a rule, meets with considerable resistance" (91).
The first encounter with the shadow is often experienced
in the form of projections. Those who identify exclusively with
their ego and are unaware of the other aspects of their being "are
wont to project their unknown 'soul parts' into the surrounding
world. These projections are seen in people who always believe
themselves to be right and just, while others are seen
as "difficult, malicious, hateful, and the source of their
troubles" (Jacobi 39). It is a time in life when every problem
seems to be caused by someone else's shortcoming, such
as a boss, a spouse, our parents, or society at large. Jung remarked
that "it is often tragic to see how blatantly a man bungles
his own life and the lives of others yet remains totally incapable
of seeing how much the whole tragedy originates in himself, and
how he continually feeds it and keep it going" (93).
Dealing with our shadow can be unpleasant for everyone
involved, and the conflicts created often fail to expand our
point of view. Many times it takes a confrontation of such a
large scale that it is referred to as a "dark night of the
soul." A person loses their job, their spouse, or possibly
their health, and suddenly realizes that the problems they have
been facing are not the fault of everyone they know. A pinnacle
is reached. They can no longer deny the unpleasant aspects of
their own personality that they have attempted to ignore, suppress
or hide. For someone with an artistic persuasion, the breakdown
can come in direct relationship to their work. It may feel as
though their creative fount has dried up, their muse has left,
or society-at-large has lost all interest in their work. This
is the same time of life when many people seek the help of a
professional psychologist to help them with such surface issues
as a divorce, depression, or the inability to find a job. But,
what they really have come for is to confront their own shadow,
and to learn how to integrate this estranged aspect of their
being back into their Self. This is the first phase of the individuation
process.
After the integration of the shadow, the unconscious
begins to manifest itself in the form of the man's anima or
the woman's animus. These unrealized inner aspects of
ourselves provide the key to the missing parts of our personality
that our outward persona may conceal. Our first encounter
with these missing parts often comes in the form of another person. "This
person is the object of intense love or equally intense hate
(or fear)" (Jung 103). However, the relationship is often
unfulfilling, because we each are really looking for something
inside ourselves. If the knowledge of the anima or animus is
continued to be repressed, it is often expressed through the
negative traits of our own personality. When men are unconscious
of their feminine anima, it can be displayed in their "moodiness,
irritability, subjective judgment, whininess, hypochondria (and)
sentimentality" (Franz 364). When women have an unrealized
masculine animus, it can make them appear "contentious,
stubborn, and sometimes brutal; or else it makes them constantly
talk at tangents to the matter at hand" (Franz 247). Yet,
not all aspects of the anima or animus are negative.
Once a person
comes to understand their relationship to their own anima or animus, there
are many positive qualities that can be assimilated. Because
of this, the anima/animus is
actively sought out in analysis via dreams or through such methods
such as "active imagination." By learning to cooperate
with this inner aspect of ourselves, there are many possible
rewards; men can gain a renewed sense of sensitivity and even
discover their artistic nature, and women can achieve a new feeling
of security, confidence and conviction. The realization of our
own anima or animus can also help reduce "illusory
projections," enhance relationships with the opposite sex,
and make people less dependant on others. Yet, this is not the
end goal of the individuation process, for a person must still
discover their true Self.
Jung defines the Self as "the totality of man, the sum
total of his conscious and unconscious contents" (242).
In many Eastern religious philosophies such as Buddhism, the
Self can be found within each human being, yet most Western religious
teachings encourage people to seek these divine aspects in symbols
outside themselves, such as God. Many people in this modern age
have found it difficult to relate to a masculine God who is always
portrayed as perfect, pure, and good. There is no room for the
evil aspects of the world, no explanation, but sin, for the shadow
side of someone's own personality. Jung recognized this conflict
in his own life, and spent most of his career helping people
find the archetypal Self inside themselves.
The Self manifests itself at various times throughout our life
in the form of symbols. These symbols may suddenly burst into
someone's consciousness in the form of an ecstatic experience
that expands their understanding of the world, or it may happen
gradually as they come to understand the symbolism behind their
dreams, creative ideas and fantasies. This is the task of "active
imagination," which "in its various forms—writing,
painting, sculpting, modeling, dancing, etc.—help to activate
the psychic depths, to maintain the vital contact between the
conscious and unconscious contents, and to express the emerging
symbols in plastic form" (Jacobi 58). These symbols often
emerge when they are needed most; at times of great conflict
or when an individual feels stuck in a rut without the answers
to their problems. The first encounter with such a symbol may
come by chance, but with practice, patience and perseverance,
it is possible to gain confidence in the process and alleviate
some of the anxiety that is felt during the period of isolation
that often proceeds contact with the unconscious.
As Aniela Jaffé points out "Artists were among the
first in our century to risk an encounter with the unconscious
and
its indefinable background" (62). The abstract and symbolist
painters of the twentieth century attempted to "penetrate
to the hidden spirit of nature and of things, to disclose the
background of life, to portray an inner reality to express the
irrational, so as to gain access to a new, vital centre" (63).
But the compulsion to create and explore the unconscious is not
without its consequences.
The inner voice that inspires individuation and creativity is
impossible for anyone to hear over the din of the masses. The
high demands of living in today's society lead most people to "follow
the line of least resistance and confine themselves to the fulfillment
of biological and materials needs" (Jacobi 17). The drive
to "have it all" and to "fit in" with social
norms leads many people away from any hope of individual development. "But
even in this unconscious social condition there are not a few
who are called awake by the summons of the voice, whereupon they
are at once set apart from the others, feeling themselves confronted
with a problem about which others know nothing." (Jung 200).
Artists are notorious for living on the margins, which also gives
them a special insight into the troubles that plague our society,
troubles that most people would rather hide or ignore. As artist
Alex Grey explains: "In a society that tries to standardize
thinking, individuality is not highly prized. Yet, it is typical
of artists to creatively individuate and stand out. [...] True
creativity depends on fostering independent thought, and the
ability to peek beyond the current cultural horizons" (27).
While individuation demands a certain degree of independence,
that same independence can bring about loneliness, isolation
and frustration.
Risk is part of the price of individuation. Jung admits, "the
right way to wholeness is made up, unfortunately, of fateful
detours and wrong turnings" (256). Struggle and suffering
are part of the painful growing process of expanding our unconscious,
which is why many people would rather avoid the effort. But,
for most artists this is not an option. "The passion and
delight of making art seduces a young artist into unknowing alliance
with the primal forces of creativity" (Grey 18).
The creative forces that exist within the unconscious are willing
partners if they are not inhibited by our own actions. Both the
individuation process and the artistic process can easily be
blocked by fear, suppressed with alcohol or drugs, or avoided
altogether, which can eventually lead to a psychotic breakdown.
Nevertheless, even breakdowns have the potential to lead to breakthroughs.
As psychologist and amateur artist Rollo May explains: "I
think it would be very important if we would value our breakdowns
more, take interest in our so-called neurotic symbols. Our breakdowns
are often the place where we discover our vocations as artists
or other professionals" (162). Each time a difficult experience
is overcome, a conflict is resolved, or a creative idea emerges
from the painful process, some confidence is gained.
Through the ongoing individuation process, an individual can
develop a relationship with the chaos of everyday life and the
darker aspects of themselves. "The capacity to create—which
we all have, though in varying degrees—is essentially the ability
to find form in chaos, to create from where there is only formlessness" (May
137). True artists are not afraid to look into the depths of
their soul and draw upon both the good and the bad for their
creative inspiration. "The artist becomes a prophetic witness
of the truth of the time and a messenger of the timeless. By
touching our deepest center, a great art transmits the condition
of the soul and awakens the healing power of the spirit" (Grey
19).
Like the artist, anyone with a consistent connection with collective
unconscious possesses enormous healing potential for their community.
Along with writing, music, and other forms of creative expression: "Art
provides a mirror for its culture. [...] Any work of art or
body of work that successfully runs the art cycle gauntlet has
the potential to influence the worldview of many individuals,
thereby subtly transforming the entire culture" (Grey 26).
Rollo May even believes that: "Good art wounds as well as
delights. It must, because our defenses against the truth are
wound so tightly around us. But as art chips away at our defenses,
it also opens us to the healing potentialities that transcend
intellectual games and ego-preserving strategies" (172).
Yet, why should someone without an artistic inclination or a
desire to heal society be interested in using the individuation
process?
Jung understood the enormous importance of helping people to
connect to the unconscious, both for individuals and for society.
Towards the end of his career in 1957, Jung wrote an essay entitled "The
Undiscovered Self" that dealt with issues such as this.
He stated that "For more than fifty years we have known,
or could have known, that there is an unconscious counterbalance
to consciousness. Medical psychology has furnished all the necessary
empirical and experimental proofs of this" (389). Still,
most of us chose to live life just as we did before we knew of
its existence. But, the world has changed and we are all more
than ever dependant on the psychic health if its inhabitants. "It
should be worthy of all the attention we can give it, especially
today, when everyone admits that the weal or woe of the future
will be decided neither by the threat of wild animals, nor by
natural catastrophes, nor by the danger of world-wide epidemics,
but simply and solely by the psychic changes in man" (390).
We, as a human race, now possess the ability to bring about our
own destruction. We also have the expertise and technology to
end such world problems as pollution, war, and famine.
Through the individuation process, Jung hoped that each of us
who heeds the call might one day reach our full potential. He
realized that if the individuals in our society could face up
to their shadows and reconnect with their inner opposites, that
we could all hopefully transcend our egotistic and destructive
nature. This could open the way for a direct connection with
the vast and humbling resources of the collective unconscious,
a resource that has long been used by poets, painters, and performers,
and is there for anyone who makes the commitment to becoming
a true individual.
Works Cited
Franz, Marie-Louise von. Archetypal Dimensions of the Psyche. Boston:
Shambhala, 1999.
Grey, Alex. The Mission of Art. Boston: Shambhala, 1998.
Jacobi, Jolande. The Way of Individuation. Trans. R.F.C.
Hull. New York: Meridian, 1983.
Jaffé, Aniela. The Myth of Meaning:
Jung and the Expansion of Consciousness. Trans. R.F.C.
Hull. New York: Penguin, 1971.
Jung, C.G. The Essential Jung. Ed. A. Storr. Princeton,
NJ: Princeton UP, 1983.
May, Rollo. My Quest for Beauty. Dallas: Saybrook, 1985.
Neumann, Eric. Art and the Creative Unconscious: Four Essays. Trans.
Ralph Manheim. New York: Harper, 1959.
|